WCGALP – Methodology

The topic of methodology in genomic EBVs was also very prominent at this conference. Already in the first plenary session, Mario Calus pointed out that this year, for the first time, more papers were submitted on genomic prediction than on GWAS and QTL prediction (Figure 1). 

On the one hand, there were sessions that were specifically dedicated to the topic of “Methods and Tools”. The topic “Genomic Selection”, in particular singlestep breeding value estimation, was also repeatedly addressed in additional sessions.  

As a first example, Daniela Lourenco from the University of Georgia presented the further development of the BLUPF90 programs. This well-known program package was fundamentally revised. It can be used mainly for variance component estimation and traditional and genomic breeding value estimation. However, it can also be used to perform many upstream and downstream processes that are important for the above methods.

Figure 1: M.Calus WCGALP 2022 Number of submitted papers on GWAS/QTL (blue) and Genomic Prediction (red). 

Figure 2: (Frischknecht et al. 2016, EAAP Belfast): Accuracy of genomic EBV with different marker densities compared to 50k density for the traits NRH: non-return rate bovine, SCS: somatic cell score and STA: sacral height. 

In the session “Challenges – Use of whole genome sequence information” several contributions were shown on how to optimize the selection of markers for genomic selection. Several years ago, we argued that there is little gain in accuracy if all imputed sequence variants are considered. This basic finding was confirmed by several presentations in this session and new methods for the selection of an optimal marker set were presented.  

single-step breeding value estimation

In singlestep breeding value estimation, genomic and phenotypic information is processed simultaneously. This new methodology is becoming the gold standard for new, as well as for traditional, traits.

 

Minna Koivula from LUKE gave a short presentation on how breeding values for milk yield traits were estimated in the Nordic Holstein breeds using the so-called ssGTBLUP model (a special form of single-step breeding value estimation) and Meta-Founders. Meta-Founders is used to model the genetics of animals that have no parental information in the pedigree. In this presentation, it was additionally shown how the information of foreign animals can be considered. 

Single step breeding value estimation does not stop at beef cattle. The presentation “Accuracy of pedigree and genomic predictions of meat quality in a multi-breed cattle using single and two step model” highlighted the importance of this new methodology for traits that are difficult to capture, such as “meat eating quality”, which includes tenderness, juiciness and flavor. This set of traits is extremely relevant to consumers. The reliability of EBVs can be improved with genomic information. The genomic breeding values for “meat eating quality” with the single-step method are now routinely published in Ireland. 

“beef-on-dairy”

Increasingly, dairy cows are being bred with beef cattle. This is called “beef-on-dairy”. Tools are being developed to obtain good predictions for this as well. An example of this was presented at the talk “Decision support tools to support a more sustainable beef-on-dairy industry”. Three methods have been developed in Ireland. The first is the Dairy Beef Index (DBI), which identifies elite beef cattle for dairy. Thanks to this index, birth traits and slaughter traits can be improved simultaneously. The second tool allows ranking of matings. With the third, the resulting progeny are ranked according to their market value. By combining these three tools, both the profitability and sustainability of the beef-on-dairy system can be improved.  

Conclusion

In summary, the full range of developments and applications of single-step breeding value estimation were presented at the World Congress. It is worth looking through the program and reading individual papers.